Could a square-1 ever have the cornercutting of a 3x3?

qwr

Legend
Joined
Jul 24, 2019
Messages
4,349
YouTube
Visit Channel
I tried out Cube Master's Little Magic squan corner mod today. It worked a little because I got like 1 mm extra of corner cutting but it's still significantly worse than even a DIY cube from like 2010. I'm no cube designer, but I tried anyway to figure out why squan corner cutting is so bad. I suspect it's because there's no vertical flex allowed since the top and bottom slices are just held in place with the ball core. There is essentially no room for the pieces in the ball core groove to flex to accommodate a corner cut.

So is it possible to introduce vertical springs for the top and bottom layers? Maybe if the each half of the ball core was split in half again for top and bottom and held together with springs. The middle which is not too important is just attached to one half. I have no idea if that would work but if it were possible to 3d print such a core it would be really funny. (Being a puzzle designer is like one of a dozen things on a list of things I could do if I weren't so goddamn lazy.)
 
Last edited:
I tried out Cube Master's Little Magic squan corner mod today. It worked a little because I got like 1 mm extra of corner cutting but it's still significantly worse than even a DIY cube from like 2010. I'm no cube designer, but I tried anyway to figure out why squan corner cutting is so bad. I suspect it's because there's no vertical flex allowed since the top and bottom slices are just held in place with the ball core. There is essentially no room for the pieces in the ball core groove to flex to accommodate a corner cut.

So is it possible to introduce vertical springs for the top and bottom layers? Maybe if the each half of the ball core was split in half again for top and bottom and held together with springs. The middle which is not too important is just attached to one half. I have no idea if that would work but if it were possible to 3d print such a core it would be really funny.
The old MoYu Weilong Squan let you adjust the two ball core halves’ height but it didn’t really make much of a difference. The squan was generally poorly designed though so if a company like QiYi were to implement it, it might help. I think that with ball cores a squabs corners would have to have a larger track size than needed to allow it to slide enough that the squan would be too flimsy and unstable.
 
The old MoYu Weilong Squan let you adjust the two ball core halves’ height but it didn’t really make much of a difference. The squan was generally poorly designed though so if a company like QiYi were to implement it, it might help. I think that with ball cores a squabs corners would have to have a larger track size than needed to allow it to slide enough that the squan would be too flimsy and unstable.
by adjust do you mean at a fixed height or with some elasticity such as with a spring? if it's a fixed height then it does nothing towards what I described
 
by adjust do you mean at a fixed height or with some elasticity such as with a spring? if it's a fixed height then it does nothing towards what I described
It had screws inside that you could loosen or tighten to allow the core to have more or less vertical elasticity.
 
Back
Top