• Welcome to the Speedsolving.com, home of the web's largest puzzle community!
    You are currently viewing our forum as a guest which gives you limited access to join discussions and access our other features.

    Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community of 35,000+ people from around the world today!

    If you are already a member, simply login to hide this message and begin participating in the community!

The influence of cubes in your times

cunningcuber

Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2011
Messages
14
Location
Look behind you...
Cubes better than the rubik's brand's lower your times.I've always wonderedhow much difference do they make.So i propose this challenge(3x3x3 only):
-Do five solves with the cube you usually use;
-Register those five times and their average (of the five times);
-Do five solves with a regular, unmoded,unlubed rubik's brand cube;
-Register those five times and their average (of the five times);
-then post those times and averages.

Example:
ZhanChi:30.00, 30.00, 30.00, 30.00, 30.00
average:30.00

rubik's cube:??.??, ??.??, ??.??, ??.??, ??.??,
average:??.??

Scrambles:
1-D R B' L' R D' F L' B' D L' F2 L' R' F D2 R U L2 D U' F' R2 B' U2

2-L2 U L' D' U2 F' D L2 F2 U L B2 L' F B2 D' F D F2 D2 B2 D' F2 B' U'

3-L' D F2 R2 D' F2 D2 R' L2 B2 U2 L2 U D' L2 D2 R' D2 F B U R B2 D' B

4-U' F2 R D2 L B' R F2 D' F2 B' L' F2 R2 L' F' L2 F U' B L F B' R' L'

5-B2 L2 D' F' D' F' D R' L' D' R' B' D R L' U' F2 D L2 R2 B' U2 D2 B2 L2

6-L F' B L2 F' R B' R D2 L2 R F2 D' R' L2 B' R2 U2 D2 F' D2 R2 D' L2 U'

7-D2 F' L2 B F' D' U2 F2 R2 D L2 R' U' R L U' L F' U B' F2 U R' B2 R2

8-F2 D L' R2 D R2 F B D2 R' D' R' B F L2 D' F' U R U' D2 R L D' L'

9-D' L' U' R B L2 U L2 R B' L2 R B' D' R2 L' D' R L2 D' U R2 L2 U2 D2

10-F2 U F L U R' U' R2 U R2 B' L2 B2 D' F R D2 B' R2 L' U2 D' R F2 D'

If you want the challenge to be even more accurate, use the same five scrambles for the both cubes.If you do this please say so.

Good luck!
 

Tao Yu

Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2011
Messages
1,113
Location
Ireland
WCA
2012YUTA01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Rubiks brand

Average of 5: 18.91
1. 19.16
2. (22.20)
3. 18.16
4. 19.43
5. (16.68) OLL skip


Guhong
Average of 5: 11.66
1. (10.75) lolwatscramble.
2. (14.10)
3. 12.38
4. 11.72
5. 10.88

I don't think we should use the same scrambles as it might give you an advantage knowing the scramble beforehand

difference of 7.25 seconds
 
Last edited:

legacy515

Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2008
Messages
3
I'd imagine not many speedcubers have a brand new storebought just lying around. I have one that has seen extremely heavy use which you might consider "modded."
 

PandaCuber

Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2011
Messages
1,689
Location
Uruguay
YouTube
Visit Channel
Okay:)
Im using a Zhanchi as my 'fast' cube and an Alpha V as my slow cube. Im using an unlubricated, unmodded, untensioned Alpha V(AV) so it really sucks.
Method: Roux

Ao5 With Zhanchi- 23.32, 24.99, 20.62, 23.89, 20.97: 22.73

Ao5 With Slow AV- 25.49, 24.02, 26.63, 27.76, 22.54: 25.38

And I did not use the same scrambles because I would already know the outcome..:fp

Extra comments: It theres not much difference, cause with the turn speed that I had lost, it made up for with the great lookahead. Yes lockups are a huge pain, but it gives you time to think.
 

aaronb

Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2011
Messages
424
Location
Maine, USA
Rubik's brand (lubed):
Ao5: 21.97
00:22.04
00:19.71
00:24.99
00:22.21
00:21.65

Lubed and Modded Zhanchi:
ao5: 16.39
00:16.82
00:18.34
00:16.25
00:16.11
00:15.47

Difference: 5.58 seconds

I like this thread, just to see how much the cubes really affects times, based on how fast you are. You always hear the "It is the cuber, not the cube." But now we can get a rough idea, of if this is true or not, or to what extent this is true.

If this thread gets enough data I will make a cute little graph. The data will look like this: (This would be the data for me)

Average: 16.39
Difference between cubes: 5.58
 

jrb

Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2011
Messages
262
Location
Sterling, VA
WCA
2011BROW01
Storebought AO5:

24.88, 30.43, 30.06, 25.52, 30.46
stats: (hide)
number of times: 5/5
best time: 24.88
worst time: 30.46

current avg5: 28.67 (σ = 2.23)
best avg5: 28.67 (σ = 2.23)

session avg: 28.67 (σ = 2.23)
session mean: 28.27

Lubix Fusion AO5:

22.80, 24.91, 19.35, 21.93, 19.32
stats: (hide)
number of times: 5/5
best time: 19.32
worst time: 24.91

current avg5: 21.36 (σ = 1.46)
best avg5: 21.36 (σ = 1.46)

session avg: 21.36 (σ = 1.46)
session mean: 21.66
 

blakedacuber

Premium Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2009
Messages
952
Location
Ireland
WCA
2010BOWE01
YouTube
Visit Channel
normal avg 17.55(my avg of 100 today)
Zhanci:
16.98
20.47
17.87
17.09
17.70

avg: 17.55 (lol)

Diansheng unmodded unlube etc( very similar to Rubik's brand imo):
37.71
34.10
36.80
29.19
32.64

avg:34.51


must say this is a good thread
 

d4m4s74

Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2008
Messages
726
Location
Holland
WCA
2009ZALI01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Today I did OH with an unmodded, new, Rubik's brand cube. Just a single solve because I might break my fingers, but it was 1:15.04 (as opposed to my average of about 45 seconds)
 

5BLD

Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2011
Messages
3,179
Location
England
WCA
2011LAUA01
YouTube
Visit Channel
A little? I thought you were the roux user with the heaviest modded rubik's brand ever that you got sub 15 with.
Yes, yes I was. Then I did this horrible mod which killed it. I sawed off bits of the edges to make it like an fii.
So the one I'm using now is a new one that I modded basically the same as the other. But not as extreme!
 

Godmil

Premium Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
2,196
Location
Aberdeen, Scotland
YouTube
Visit Channel
Excellent thread idea, can't wait to try my solves. What I'm interested in graphing out is the percentage difference.
It's good to see evidence that kills the "It's the cuber not the cube" mantra that is too often misused.
 

MostEd

Member
Joined
May 21, 2011
Messages
424
Location
St. Petersburg Russia
WCA
2012BETA01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Rubik's Brand Modded, lubed(the best rubik's cube out of the 2)
32.99, 25.36, 28.76, 33.21, 31.94
avg5: 31.23 (σ = 1.80)

Rubik's Brand Barely modded litle lubed(sucks kinda)
29.03, 34.21, 22.21, 33.04, 25.82
avg5: 29.30 (σ = 2.95)

Dayan Guhong(modded, lubed, really nice)
27.74, 33.42, 24.19, 28.97, 23.06
avg5: 26.97 (σ = 2.03)

There, used the same scrambles, actually JK.

Used QQ timer ones, seriously i rarely do poster scrambles
 
Last edited:

Lucas Garron

Member
Joined
Jul 6, 2007
Messages
3,559
Location
California
WCA
2006GARR01
YouTube
Visit Channel
It was about 7pm when I did these solves and ive been cubing all day, so i dont think its a HUGE factor.
No, how do you account for hands getting warmed up throughout the session? I'm just noting that you should be careful that things like what order you try the cubes in might make a significant difference in times. Maybe it doesn't, but you're measuring exactly that difference – so you can't tell when it does.

(Note that a storebought might be easier to turn with hands that have been doing a few solves, while a good cube always handles decently. Or maybe it would be the other around, too: Storeboughts make your hands apply more force, which makes good cubes easier to turn consistently.)
 

Thorsten

Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
26
Location
Hanover, Germany
YouTube
Visit Channel
Rubiks Brand (lubed, but not played in, horrible cube):
Avg. of 5: 35.06

Rubiks Brand (lubed, broken in, my first cube):
Avg. of 5: 30:75

Guhong (lubed, modded, broken in, main cube):
Avg. of 5: 26:06 (can do better^^)
 
Top