• Welcome to the Speedsolving.com, home of the web's largest puzzle community!
    You are currently viewing our forum as a guest which gives you limited access to join discussions and access our other features.

    Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community of 40,000+ people from around the world today!

    If you are already a member, simply login to hide this message and begin participating in the community!

T1_M0

Member
Joined
Feb 13, 2017
Messages
578
Location
Finland
WCA
2017NORR01
YouTube
Visit Channel
does anyone have a good list of commutators i can use for fmc? I just got into this and im starting from cfop, and as it is known, cfop is pretty bad in fmc. all i know for edges is u perm (but i do know the optimal one) and all i know for corners is a perm.
You should learn them intuively (at least the corners first)
 

ChrisCuber123

Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
47
Location
Bayside, New York, United States
WCA
2014CHIC01
dadams weekly:
D' F2 L F' // EO
L F2 U2 // 2x2x2
U L2 U' // 2x2x3
L D' L' // F2L-1
R' D' R D2 // L4C

skeleton: D' F2 L F' L F2 U' L2 ^ U' L D' L' * R' D' R D2
*: D' L' D R' D' L D R
^: L B' L' F' L B L' F
final solution: D' F2 L F' L F2 U' L' B' L' F' L B L' F U' L D' L' D' L' D R' D' L R D2 (27)

messed around with other starts finding nothing good for like 30 minutes, then found this skeleton in like 30 seconds :p
 

guysensei1

Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2013
Messages
5,143
Location
singapore
WCA
2014WENW01
dadams weekly:
D' F2 L F' // EO
L F2 U2 // 2x2x2
U L2 U' // 2x2x3
L D' L' // F2L-1
R' D' R D2 // L4C

skeleton: D' F2 L F' L F2 U' L2 ^ U' L D' L' * R' D' R D2
*: D' L' D R' D' L D R
^: L B' L' F' L B L' F
final solution: D' F2 L F' L F2 U' L' B' L' F' L B L' F U' L D' L' D' L' D R' D' L R D2 (27)

messed around with other starts finding nothing good for like 30 minutes, then found this skeleton in like 30 seconds :p
Ayylmao we have the exact same skeleton. I posted mine on the previous page XD
 

Neuro

Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2016
Messages
597
Well I got a 28, but I feel it could've beeen a lot better. Can someone please show me a better solution with an explanation? I would greatly appreciate any help! Thank you!

SCRAMBLE: D2 F2 U' L2 F2 D B2 D' F2 L2 B2 L U F2 R' U B L' D B' D'

D' B' R F2 D' F2 L//2x2x3 (7/7)
F D' F'//EO (3/10)
R D R2 * D' R2 D' R D2 R2 D//L4C (10/20)

*=R2 D F U2 F' D' R2 D2 B L2 B' D2

Final Solution: D' B' R F2 D' F2 L F D' F' R D2 F U2 F' D' R2 D2 B L2 B' D R2 D' R D2 R2 D
 

guysensei1

Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2013
Messages
5,143
Location
singapore
WCA
2014WENW01
Well I got a 28, but I feel it could've beeen a lot better. Can someone please show me a better solution with an explanation? I would greatly appreciate any help! Thank you!

SCRAMBLE: D2 F2 U' L2 F2 D B2 D' F2 L2 B2 L U F2 R' U B L' D B' D'

D' B' R F2 D' F2 L//2x2x3 (7/7)
F D' F'//EO (3/10)
R D R2 * D' R2 D' R D2 R2 D//L4C (10/20)

*=R2 D F U2 F' D' R2 D2 B L2 B' D2

Final Solution: D' B' R F2 D' F2 L F D' F' R D2 F U2 F' D' R2 D2 B L2 B' D R2 D' R D2 R2 D
D' B' R F2 D' F2 L //your 2x2x3 (7/7)
D B R2 B' D' //almost an f2l, minus a cross edge (5/12)
At this point, first I tried the obvious
R2 F B' D2 F' B//insert that cross edge (6/18)
U' B2 D2 L' D' L D' B2 U R//zbll (10/28)

great! already tied your solution :) But we can do better. Notice that the moves to insert the cross edge is just an edge commutator. We can leave that out and do that as an insertion.

D' B' R F2 D' F2 L //your 2x2x3 (7/7)
D B R2 B' D' //almost an f2l, minus a cross edge (5/12)
U' B2 D2 L' D' L D' B2 U R//3E (10/22)

turns out the optimal insertion requires swapping the underlined moves (which is something I neglect myself, I need to be more careful to check for these)

D' B' R F2 D' F2 L D B R2 B' U' * D' B2 D2 L' D' L D' B2 U R

*=R' L B2 R L' D2

so we get

D' B' R F2 D' F2 L D B R2 B' U' R' L B2 R L' D B2 D2 L' D' L D' B2 U R (27)
 

Theo Leinad

Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2017
Messages
54
WCA
2016CUEV04
How would you finish following scramble with given steps until F2L-1:

Scramble:
R' U' F D' L2 U2 F2 U B2 U' R2 B2 U2 L B R2 D B' F U' F' U2 R' U2 R' U' F

Steps:
D' B D L2 D2 B L2 (222) x7
B U' R' (221) x3
U' R' U' (Pseudo F2L-1) x3
R2 B' R B R2 (F2L-1) x5
...
 

Rcuber123

Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2014
Messages
873
Location
At your house stealing your cubes
WCA
2014TAMI01
dadams weekly:
D' F2 L F' // EO
L F2 U2 // 2x2x2
U L2 U' // 2x2x3
L D' L' // F2L-1
R' D' R D2 // L4C

skeleton: D' F2 L F' L F2 U' L2 ^ U' L D' L' * R' D' R D2
*: D' L' D R' D' L D R
^: L B' L' F' L B L' F
final solution: D' F2 L F' L F2 U' L' B' L' F' L B L' F U' L D' L' D' L' D R' D' L R D2 (27)

messed around with other starts finding nothing good for like 30 minutes, then found this skeleton in like 30 seconds :p
I found that skeleton but I also found a 16 moves to l4c skeleton and a 15 moves to good l5c but optimal for all of them was 27...
 

guysensei1

Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2013
Messages
5,143
Location
singapore
WCA
2014WENW01
weekly fmc, 27
s: F' B R' B R' F L' U R' B' D' R B2 L2 R' B' D2 L F R'

Inverse with premove R, (1/1)
F' L B2 U' L' B//2x2x2 (6/7)
R' F//two squares (2/9)
L D L' D//2x2x3 with random inefficiency (4/13)
R2//F2L-1 (1/14)
U' R U R'//F2L (4/18)
L' F' L' U L U' F L F'//LL (9/27)

final: R' F L' F' U L' U' L F L R U' R' U R2 D' L D' L' F' R B' L U B2 L' F (27)

yay for freefop
 

Bubtore

Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2012
Messages
98
Location
Vevey, Switzerland
WCA
2012BUBE01
YouTube
Visit Channel
26.00 Swiss NR mean solutions :

S // R' U' F D2 R2 B2 L2 F2 R2 D' U' R U R2 D2 B' U2 R2 B R' B' L2 F' R' U' F
F' B R' B' D2 F' D' F R' * // 222 + EO
B2 D2 L' // 223
D2 B2 D2 B2 // Tripod
R D R' D' // 3C

* R F R' B R F' R' B'
Solution // F' B R' B' D2 F' D' F2 R' B R F' R' B D2 L' D2 B2 D2 B2 R D R' D' - 24 Moves

S // R' U' F R' U2 L B2 D2 R' D2 R F2 L' F' R' D' B' U L' U2 R2 B D R' U' F
I // F' U R D' B' R2 U2 L U' B D R F L F2 R' D2 R D2 B2 L' U2 R F' U R

(L' B' D2 B2) // 122
(U F U F) // EO
(R2 L' D' R' B2 L) // 223
(L U L' B2 U2) // 4C

Skel // U2 B2 L U' L2 B2 * R D + L R2 F' U' F' U' B2 D2 B L - 18
* B L2 B' R B L2 B' R'
+ D R D' L' D R' D' L
Solution // U2 B2 L U' L2 B' L2 B' R B L2 B' D2 R D' L' D R' D' L2 R2 F' U' F' U' B2 D2 B L - 29 Moves

S // R' U' F R2 D2 F2 R2 B' D2 R2 B R2 B L R B' L2 F L' B' L' U B R' U' F
I // F' U R B' U' L B L F' L2 B R' L' B' R2 B' R2 D2 B R2 F2 D2 R2 F' U R

(F2 L2 B') // EO
(D F2 L' D2) // 222
(U2 L * B2 L2 B2) // 223
(U L' U' L2 U' L2 U L) // 3C

* L' B R2 B' L B R2 B'
Solution // L' U' L2 U L2 U L U' B2 L2 B' R2 B' L' B R2 B' U2 D2 L F2 D' B L2 F2 - 25 Moves
 

ChrisCuber123

Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
47
Location
Bayside, New York, United States
WCA
2014CHIC01
26.00 Swiss NR mean solutions :

S // R' U' F D2 R2 B2 L2 F2 R2 D' U' R U R2 D2 B' U2 R2 B R' B' L2 F' R' U' F
F' B R' B' D2 F' D' F R' * // 222 + EO
B2 D2 L' // 223
D2 B2 D2 B2 // Tripod
R D R' D' // 3C

* R F R' B R F' R' B'
Solution // F' B R' B' D2 F' D' F2 R' B R F' R' B D2 L' D2 B2 D2 B2 R D R' D' - 24 Moves

S // R' U' F R' U2 L B2 D2 R' D2 R F2 L' F' R' D' B' U L' U2 R2 B D R' U' F
I // F' U R D' B' R2 U2 L U' B D R F L F2 R' D2 R D2 B2 L' U2 R F' U R

(L' B' D2 B2) // 122
(U F U F) // EO
(R2 L' D' R' B2 L) // 223
(L U L' B2 U2) // 4C

Skel // U2 B2 L U' L2 B2 * R D + L R2 F' U' F' U' B2 D2 B L - 18
* B L2 B' R B L2 B' R'
+ D R D' L' D R' D' L
Solution // U2 B2 L U' L2 B' L2 B' R B L2 B' D2 R D' L' D R' D' L2 R2 F' U' F' U' B2 D2 B L - 29 Moves

S // R' U' F R2 D2 F2 R2 B' D2 R2 B R2 B L R B' L2 F L' B' L' U B R' U' F
I // F' U R B' U' L B L F' L2 B R' L' B' R2 B' R2 D2 B R2 F2 D2 R2 F' U R

(F2 L2 B') // EO
(D F2 L' D2) // 222
(U2 L * B2 L2 B2) // 223
(U L' U' L2 U' L2 U L) // 3C

* L' B R2 B' L B R2 B'
Solution // L' U' L2 U L2 U L U' B2 L2 B' R2 B' L' B R2 B' U2 D2 L F2 D' B L2 F2 - 25 Moves

Nice mean! I tried these scrambles, here are my solutions:

1. F' R' D B2 L' F' L B2 L' F D' L U L' D' L D' R2 D' U' R D' R' D' U2 F' U2 L' (28 moves)
F' (L U2 F) // EO (4/4)
R' U (U') // 2x2x2 (3/7)
D L' D2 L // 2x2x3 (4/11)
D' R2 // F2L-1 - 1C (2/13)
D' U' R D' R' D' U // L5C (6/19)
skeleton: F' R' D * U L' D2 L D' R2 D' U' R D' R' D' U2 F' U2 L' (19)
*: L' ^ D' L U L' D L U' (3/22)
^: L B2 L' F' L B2 L' F (6/28)

2. R2 D B' R' B2 F2 R U' L2 U R U' L U R2 U' L U' L2 D U R U' R2 U R' U B (28 moves)
(B') R2 D B' // EO (4/4)
R' B2 F2 U2 L2 D U // psF2L-1 - 1C (7/11)
R U' R2 U R' U // L5C (6/17)
skeleton: R2 D B' R' B2 F2 * U2 L2 D U R U' R2 U R' U B (17)
*: R2 ^ U' L' U R2 U' L U (7/24)
^: R' U' L2 U R U' L2 U (4/28)

3. U D' L U' L' D U' L U R' U2 R U2 D2 L F' D B D' F' D B' D2 B L2 F2 (26 moves)
(F2 L2 B') // EO (3/3)
(D F2 L' D2) // 2x2x2 (4/7)
(U2 R' U2 R) // 2x2x3 (4/11)
(U' L' U L U L' U') // L5C (7/18)
skeleton: U * L U' L' U' L U R' U2 R U2 D2 L F2 ^ D' B L2 F2
*: D' L U' L' D L U L' (2/20)
^: F D B D' F' D B' D' (6/26)

28, 28, 26 = 27.33 mean
 

Theo Leinad

Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2017
Messages
54
WCA
2016CUEV04
Hello people,
I have a suggestion for the ultimate FMC technique, please help me understanding if this approach is good or not :)
The steps to follow are pretty simple, this just came to my mind and need help to summarize and get the numbers right.
1. EO is very recommendable (3-4movs)
2. Do all the edges (Skeleton) (10-14? movs)
3. L8C (3 Inserts Avg) in some cases we might find less corners to solve (we called them lucky corners)

So in Step 1, I would like to know how many moves are required to have all the edges solved.
In step 2, if we only focus on 8 movers for insertions, it should be about 24 moves avg minus cancelled moves.
Steps to improve (Corner Orientation)

Does anyone have tried this?
Why is this or is not optimal?
Any comments?

Thank you.
 

sqAree

Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
858
Location
Berlin
WCA
2015JAEH01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Hello people,
I have a suggestion for the ultimate FMC technique, please help me understanding if this approach is good or not :)
The steps to follow are pretty simple, this just came to my mind and need help to summarize and get the numbers right.
1. EO is very recommendable (3-4movs)
2. Do all the edges (Skeleton) (10-14? movs)
3. L8C (3 Inserts Avg) in some cases we might find less corners to solve (we called them lucky corners)

So in Step 1, I would like to know how many moves are required to have all the edges solved.
In step 2, if we only focus on 8 movers for insertions, it should be about 24 moves avg minus cancelled moves.
Steps to improve (Corner Orientation)

Does anyone have tried this?
Why is this or is not optimal?
Any comments?

Thank you.

Hm, I'd say 8 corners are not solvable with 3 comms most of the time especially as there might be twisted corners. But even without those it doesn't seem too likely.
But even if, with 24 + 10 + 3 = 37 moves we get a quite bad result considering world class FMC cubers average consistently sub30 moves. There won't be too many cancellations as it's a quite short skeleton in the beginning and even just two insertions can be hard to get optimal.
 

Theo Leinad

Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2017
Messages
54
WCA
2016CUEV04
Well, after first insertion, skeleton gets larger, so you can insert next set of corners, but remember since you have 2 insertions, you might be able to do the last insert instead of the second one...
You have many options for the insertions...
But it's true, it'll be hard to do optimal inserts..
I'm aiming to reduce the skeleton to sub 30 with this technique...
As I stated, this just came to my mind, so need to try it a couple of times to see if its powerful or not :)
 

ChrisCuber123

Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
47
Location
Bayside, New York, United States
WCA
2014CHIC01
Hello people,
I have a suggestion for the ultimate FMC technique, please help me understanding if this approach is good or not :)
The steps to follow are pretty simple, this just came to my mind and need help to summarize and get the numbers right.
1. EO is very recommendable (3-4movs)
2. Do all the edges (Skeleton) (10-14? movs)
3. L8C (3 Inserts Avg) in some cases we might find less corners to solve (we called them lucky corners)

So in Step 1, I would like to know how many moves are required to have all the edges solved.
In step 2, if we only focus on 8 movers for insertions, it should be about 24 moves avg minus cancelled moves.
Steps to improve (Corner Orientation)

Does anyone have tried this?
Why is this or is not optimal?
Any comments?

Thank you.

This just won't work. It's pretty rare that you can solve 8 corners in 3 comms, often you'll need 4 or 5. This makes adding 32-40 moves to a 15ish moves skeleton, minus cancellations. Even if you get 1 or 2 corners solved unintentionally, it's still pretty likely that a corner or 2 will be twisted. It's much more efficient to make blocks and solve up to a 3c/4c/5c skeleton
 

hagner

Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2016
Messages
68
Location
finland
dadams weekly fmc 188

pb 32

scramble: F' L U F B2 U2 F2 L' B D U2 F R' D2 F B L R2 F L'

(U) B2 R2 F //2x2x2 inserted move in ( )
(B) U’ B’ L’ B’ R’ B2’ R’ B2 L B’ //F2L-1 inserted move in ( )
R U R2 U’ R2 U’ R2 U2 //last pair and OLL “cancelled move(s)”
R’ F2 R’ B’ R F2 R’ B R’ //A perm “cancelled move(s)”
 

BenBergen

Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2015
Messages
107
Location
Canada!
WCA
2015BERG10
28 - new PB

B2 L2 R U2 L2 U2 F2 R' B2 D2 B2 U L' D' U' L F' R U2 B' L2

L2 B' * R' U' F L B2 // 2x2x2
U R2 U2 R F' R U // 2x2x3
R2 D' F' D // EO
F' R2 // F2L-1

By some miracle, after F2L-1 I was left with only a corner 3-cycle. I couldn't solve it with an 8-mover right away, so I found a spot in the solve where I could insert an 8-move commutator.

* - D F2 D' B' D F2 D' B // L3C

Unfortuantely, I ran out of time before finding an insertion with any cancellations. This could have easily been a 26 or 27 with an extra 10 minutes.

L2 B' D F2 D' B' D F2 D' B R' U' F L B2 U R2 U2 R F' R U R2 D' F' D F' R2
 

Jaysammey777

Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2009
Messages
1,217
Location
University of Georgia
WCA
2010AMBR01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Michigan 2017: 39, 27, 29

Redid Scramble 1 and found this in under 10 minutes:
Scramble: R' U' F U2 F2 D' L2 U2 B2 U' B2 F2 U' L' U2 R B' L D' U F' L' B' D R' U' F

2x2x2:(R' B' U2 D' F) (5/5)
2x2x3: (L U2 L U B2) (5/10)
F2L-1: (L2 U' L2) (3/13)
F2L: (B' U' B) (3/16)
AB3C: (B L U' L' B' R' U R) (7/23)
Insertion finder cancels 2 for 29 :(
Didn't really look for more, pretty sad could have gotten a 28.33 mean :(
 
Top