I'm also positive he wouldn't cheat, and I know it's the judge's fault for not paying attention to a very crucial rule, I just wanted to be sure.
Why are you so positive he wouldn't cheat? If it's because he has a blindfold world record, I think we can all agree that that's not proven to be a very good method.
I'm not saying I have any reason to believe he cheated (I don't, and I don't think he did), I just don't think getting good BLD times is reason enough to be completely trusted. There's only a few people whom I'm completely, positively sure would not peek when presented an easy opportunity to do so. I'm not saying that anyone is dishonest, I'm just saying that I don't have any reason to know for sure for most people, especially for people I've never met.
Why are you questioning his trust in the WR holder when you have the same trust? The reasons you don't think he cheated are probably the same reasons that Bobby doesn't think that he cheated.