Reviews Section

So, I had an idea just now that maybe we could cut down on the number of "What's the best x?" posts by making a reviews subforum in the hardware area in which people could post reviews of any cube or hardware item they like. Thus someone with a question could be redirected to the reviews subforum where they could find everyone's opinions on puzzles. Just a thought, but it might be a futile effort nonetheless.

I think the real problem is that after being redirected, people will continue posting on that thread.

soccerking813 said:

I think the real problem is that after being redirected, people will continue posting on that thread.

Click to expand...

Which thread, the original or one in the reviews section?

The thread where the newbie asks what cube is the best.

Maybe just lock the original upon referral? Not sure how you would solve that problem, but I don't see why people would continue to post after:

Post 1: Question
Post 2: Link
Post 3: Thanks.

We could just close the thread...

Edit: JTW2007 beat me

Reviews are fine on youtube. There are far too many reviews out there. It's all a matter of preference. Besides, look at any what kind of cube is best thread. Tell me if you see an ounce of consistency in the opinions.

Sn3kyPandaMan said:

Reviews are fine on youtube. There are far too many reviews out there. It's all a matter of preference. Besides, look at any what kind of cube is best thread. Tell me if you see an ounce of consistency in the opinions.

Click to expand...

I didn't mean a section where you recommend things based on personal opinion. I was suggesting a place to consolidate empirical observations about puzzles that help unexperienced people to determine which puzzle matches their personal needs. I would need to be less "I highly recommend this cube because of (bias)." and more of a rating system like: "Cornering: 7/10, Smoothness: 5/10" etc. Sort of like the 3x3 comparison in the hardware section, but for all puzzles and miscellaneous (stickers, lube, modding tools, etc.).