View Poll Results: Zhanchi Or Guhong V2?

Voters
173. You may not vote on this poll
  • Zhanchi

    100 57.80%
  • Guhong V2

    73 42.20%
Page 1 of 13 1 2 3 11 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 125

Thread: DaYan Zhanchi vs GuHong

  1. #1
    Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Seoul, Korea, South Korea
    YouTube
    kimcuber
    Posts
    1,089

    Default DaYan Zhanchi vs GuHong

    This review will mainly compare the Zhanchi and the GuHong (Read THIS before reading this review ).

    I will not give this cube, or any cube, a 10/10, because no cube is ever perfect.
    This cube was lubed only by Maru lube, and has been broken in for about a week.
    This cube HAS the anchors (hooks) on the edges, just because it was already assembled with them on.

    First Impressions of the Zhanchi

    When I opened the box, it was stickered with standard Dayan (dull) stickers and had no lube on it. It was quite stiff and hard to turn. The edges and corners were quite sharp and unfriendly in many areas, and as soon as I unboxed the cube, I had to take my exacto knife and smooth down the sharp edges and corners. The stickers were moderate, although a bit dull. After lubed with Maru lube, the cube was flying fast.

    Pictures



    The unstickered Zhanchi.



    The two corners and one edge of the Zhanchi (after lubed).



    The core and inner pieces of the unstickered Zhanchi.



    [Top] Zhanchi corners and edge
    [Bottom] GuHong corners and edge



    The insides of the Zhanchi (unstickered) and the GuHong (stickered).



    [Left] GuHong
    [Right] ZhanChi

    Rating

    Smoothness : 8.8/10
    Speed : 9.9/10
    Corner cutting : 9.7/10
    Stability (popping frequency) : 9.9/10
    Reliability (how crazy you can turn without lock-up or pops) : 8.4/10
    Lockup resistance : 7.1/10
    Quality (of plastic, core, etc) : 9.4/10
    Quietness : 8.1/10
    Feel : crisp, fast
    Overall : One of the fastest cubes I've owned, and maybe even too fast. Speed, corner-cutting, stability and the quality of the cube is outstanding, but as you can see, the others may lack a bit compared to the GuHong.

    THE Review

    Smoothness (8.8/10) - This cube, compared to the GuHong, is quite crisp. It is also slightly clicky, but other than those two, the Zhanchi is fine off in smoothness. The GuHong, with a rating of 9.9/10 in smoothness, is by far the winner in this category.

    Speed (9.9/10) - VERY fast, almost uncontrollably fast. The GuHong, in the other hand, is quite slow and mushy, which is why it got a 8.4/10 in the category of speed.

    Corner cutting (9.7/10) - As expected, the Zhanchi is almost perfect in corner cutting. With the exception of accidently cutting the opposite direction, this cube has the best corner cutting ability I have ever seen in a cube. The Zhanchi wins the Guhong by 0.3 points in corner cutting.

    Stability (popping frequency) (9.9/10) - With the anchors (hooks) on, the Zhanchi will NOT pop, unless you do abnormal things to your cube. Although I haven't tried the cube without anchors, I'm pretty sure even without them, the Zhanchi will win this category. (GuHong - 8.8/10)

    Reliability (how crazy you can turn without lock-up or pops) (8.4/10) - The pops are not a problem in this cube, but rather the lockups due to the speed of the cube. Lockups are also caused by accidental corner cuts in wrong directions. The GuHong is also rated 8.4 because of its frequent pops, with no lockups.

    Lockup resistance (7.1/10) - The Zhanchi's uncontrollable speed is probably its worst quality, because it causes many other problems, such as lock ups, therefore, I gave the cube a low score. The GuHong, in the other hand, is outstanding with Lockup resistance and was given a 9.1/10.

    Quality (9.4/10) - The quality of the plastic was fine, but the sharp, uncut edges of the edges and corners of the cube was quiet disappointing. The GuHong (although I think Cameron may have smoothened the sharp edges) gets a 9.8/10.

    Quietness (8.1/10) - It's loud, crispy and clicky. Nothing more. The GuHong is quiet, creamy and smooth, which is why it got a 9.7/10 in quietness.

    Feel (crispy, clicky) - Compared to the GuHong, the Zhanchi is quite rough. Although this is personal preference, I think I may like the crisp and fastness of the Zhanchi over the smooth, creamy feel of the GuHong.

    Overall

    The DaYan Zhanchi is a well rounded cube, rating wise, with many pros and cons.

    Pros: Fast, excellent in cutting corners, little to no popping, fine quality plastic (with the exception of the sharp edges)

    Cons: Loud, a lot of lockups, not very smooth.

    Comparison to the GuHong

    I think in the end, the Zhanchi and GuHong are both very fine cubes, but are very different.
    The crisp, fastness of the Zhanchi and the smooth, quiet feel of the GuHong are mainly depended on one's personal preference.
    So in other words, if you like quiet, smooth cubes, I recommend you to buy the GuHong, but if you like fast, clicky cubes, I recommend you to try out the Zhanchi.
    Last edited by koreancuber; 08-15-2011 at 06:10 AM.

  2. #2
    Member Engberg91's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Location
    Sweden
    WCA Profile
    2011ENGB02
    YouTube
    Engberg711
    Posts
    169

    Default

    very very good review!

  3. #3
    Premium Member Muesli's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Sheffield, UK
    WCA Profile
    2009SMIT05
    YouTube
    musli4brekkies
    Posts
    1,713

    Default

    Very nicely done, however.
    a lot of lockups
    I disagree. Try tightening the Zhanchi. I only ever get lockups on my cube if I'm doing something spectacularly stupid.
    My team sucks.

  4. #4
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    47

    Default

    was the guhong fresh out of the box?
    i recently got a pink guhong and a white zhanchi. and the zhanchi is completely smooth but the guhong clicky (completely different to my heavily used black lubix ultimate guhong, which is very smooth).

  5. #5
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Australia, mate.
    Posts
    560

    Default

    Oh. My. Freaking. Gosh. Another post from KoreanCuber! Hi btw. /offtopic

    Nice review, I've been hearing nothing but good reviews of the Zhanchi. I'm feeling really compelled to hurry up and buy one.

  6. #6
    Premium Member JLarsen's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Dover, New Hampshire, USA
    WCA Profile
    2009LARS03
    YouTube
    Sn3kyPandaMan
    Posts
    1,879

    Default

    Sand down the bottom of the corners where the T parts catch on the molding imperfections and then tell us what you think.
    Josh "SneakyPanda" Larsen -- Trying Freefop for a while -- Wrist problems...-- Current Best Freefop Avg 12: 15.47

  7. #7
    Member
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Posts
    146

    Default

    Good review, but I don't think you should stereotype the two cubes too much like that. In other words, I wouldn't particularly say something like "go for the Gu Hong if you like a smooth, creamy feel and go for the Zhanchi if you like a crispy, clicky feel." I feel that may not be entirely true and surely, the difference certainly can't be as big as it is for the F-II versus A-V.
    PB: Official: , Freestyle

  8. #8
    Member Winston Yang's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Location
    San Gabriel, California, United States
    Posts
    127

    Default

    Excellent job posting this!
    Records: 3x3x3:34:00 [PLL Skip] [Modified Zhanchi] 4x4x4:03:40.27[Shengshou V3]
    Wishlist:Wit 2x2x2 Godly Guhong 3x3x3 Shengshou 5x5x5

  9. #9
    Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Seoul, Korea, South Korea
    YouTube
    kimcuber
    Posts
    1,089

    Default

    Thanks to all!
    @SneakyPMan - I'll try it out and add more to the original post
    @Innocence - HAI
    BigGreen: CHOSONOON HANADA!

  10. #10
    Premium Member JLarsen's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Dover, New Hampshire, USA
    WCA Profile
    2009LARS03
    YouTube
    Sn3kyPandaMan
    Posts
    1,879

    Default

    Did you ever try touching up the corners?
    Josh "SneakyPanda" Larsen -- Trying Freefop for a while -- Wrist problems...-- Current Best Freefop Avg 12: 15.47

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •