• Welcome to the Speedsolving.com, home of the web's largest puzzle community!
    You are currently viewing our forum as a guest which gives you limited access to join discussions and access our other features.

    Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community of 40,000+ people from around the world today!

    If you are already a member, simply login to hide this message and begin participating in the community!

Probability Thread

Riley

Member
Joined
May 14, 2011
Messages
1,303
Location
California
WCA
2007WOOR01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Are the chances of getting an LL skip with winter variation (as in you have winter variation in the current solve) 1/22? Because there are 21 PLL's you might get and 1 just solved last layer? (don't count AUF's) Thanks.
 

Riley

Member
Joined
May 14, 2011
Messages
1,303
Location
California
WCA
2007WOOR01
YouTube
Visit Channel
If you're just orienting the corners, then it would be 1/63.

Otherwise, no idea. You might also have to include half the F2L's, since mirrors make no extra contribution.

I'm trying to say, if you have a R U' R' insertion with 3 edges on the top layer that are already correct (like yellow facing up, if white was your cross color), what is the chance of an LL skip, using WV, so that the corners orient? No mirrors. And if it's still 63, can you please explain how you get that? Thanks!
 

Rpotts

Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2008
Messages
1,871
Location
KC
WCA
2010POTT01
YouTube
Visit Channel
I'm trying to say, if you have a R U' R' insertion with 3 edges on the top layer that are already correct (like yellow facing up, if white was your cross color), what is the chance of an LL skip, using WV, so that the corners orient? No mirrors. And if it's still 63, can you please explain how you get that? Thanks!

Same chance as a PLL skip - 1/72
 

IanTheCuber

Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2011
Messages
215
Location
In the clouds
WCA
2013SCAH01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Here is a good one: What is the propability of getting a Sub-30 solve on 4x4, considering your average is about 37 seconds, and about 1/150 you get is Sub-35? I don't think there is enough info to make the answer out, but try. I am.
 

Godmil

Premium Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
2,203
Location
Aberdeen, Scotland
YouTube
Visit Channel
Here is a good one: What is the propability of getting a Sub-30 solve on 4x4, considering your average is about 37 seconds, and about 1/150 you get is Sub-35? I don't think there is enough info to make the answer out, but try. I am.

Hmm, you know you could probably draw a probability distribution, like a gaussian or something with the 1/150 defining the width. Should be possible to get a rough estimate. But I don't know how to do it :p
 

MTGjumper

Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2008
Messages
2,212
Location
Bath/Notts
WCA
2008CRAW01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Here is a good one: What is the propability of getting a Sub-30 solve on 4x4, considering your average is about 37 seconds, and about 1/150 you get is Sub-35? I don't think there is enough info to make the answer out, but try. I am.

I doubt that someone who averaged 37 would only get a sub-35 one in 150 solves. But a normal distribution should work, providing you chose the variance such that 1/150 solves was sub-35.
 

ben1996123

Banned
Joined
May 17, 2009
Messages
4,972
Location
Ponyville
WCA
2009WHIT01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Here is a good one: What is the propability of getting a Sub-30 solve on 4x4, considering your average is about 37 seconds, and about 1/150 you get is Sub-35? I don't think there is enough info to make the answer out, but try. I am.

Assuming the solve time, X is random and normally distributed:

X ~ N(37, σ)
P(X < 35) = 0.0067
P(Z < -2/σ) = 0.0067
P(Z < 2/σ) = 0.9933
2/σ = 2.48
σ = 2/2.48 = 0.806
X ~ N(37, 0.806)
P(X < 30) = P(Z < (30-37)/0.806) = P(Z < -8.685) = 0.0000000000000001894%
 
Last edited:

ben1996123

Banned
Joined
May 17, 2009
Messages
4,972
Location
Ponyville
WCA
2009WHIT01
YouTube
Visit Channel
After solving the centres on a 4x4, how many possible states are there?

Attempt:

Edge permutations(24!) * Corner permutations(8!) * Corner orientations(3^7) = 54711040793092776444454502400000

So the probability of a centres skip on 4x4 is 54711040793092776444454502400000/7401196841564901869874093974498574336000000000 = \( \frac{1}{135277939046250} \)

Or do I need to divide something by 24 somewhere?
 

TMOY

Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Messages
1,802
WCA
2008COUR01
Seems correct to me. Once the centers are solved, the orientation of the cube is fixed, so you don't have to divide by 24.
 

CubeRoots

Member
Joined
Mar 22, 2012
Messages
538
Location
Leicester, UK
WCA
2012LIVS01
YouTube
Visit Channel
Well, it's pretty easy. Assume there are actually 73 different PLL cases, counting different orientations separately. Since 73 is prime, this is only possible if there are 73 pieces of the same kind on the LL; this is obviously not the case, hence your logic must be wrong :p

Actually the correct result for the cube ls 1/72. But as Rpotts pointed out, we were talking about the megaminx, for which the correct result is 1/720. (There are 60 possible permutations of corners (5!/2, since only even permutations are possible), same for edges, hence 3600 possibilities disregarding AUF, hence the probability of a PLL skip is 1 out of 3600/5=720.)

I know this was 2 weeks ago but i realised mistake, I thought there were 2 ways to get Hperm but in reality there was only one so i ended up with 73 instead of 72 possibilities
 

Akash Rupela

Member
Joined
May 9, 2011
Messages
472
Location
New Delhi, India, India
WCA
2012RUPE01
YouTube
Visit Channel
probability that corners are correctly oriented after f2l=?
Probability that corners are correctly solved after f2l?
Probability that no corner is correctly oriented after f2l?
Probability that edges are correctly solved after f2l?
Probability that No edge is correctly oriented after f2l?
 

ben1996123

Banned
Joined
May 17, 2009
Messages
4,972
Location
Ponyville
WCA
2009WHIT01
YouTube
Visit Channel
What is the probability that after a random 3x3 scramble, one side will be solved (not necessarily a layer, just a face)? Just curious because I got this scramble about a week ago: R2 B2 R2 D' L2 D F2 U F2 L2 D2 F U2 F D' F2 R' F D L2 F D'

7 greens on F. I think I had one other scramble like this some time last year too, but I've never had one with 8 or 9.

Edit: Might as well have a go at calculating it myself:

edge permutations: 4! = 24
edge orientations: 2^4 = 16
corner permutations: 4! = 24
corner orientations: 3^4 = 81
centres: 6

1/(24*16*24*81*6) = \( \frac{1}{4478976} \)

not sure if its correct.
 
Last edited:

cuBerBruce

Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2006
Messages
914
Location
Malden, MA, USA
WCA
2006NORS01
YouTube
Visit Channel
What is the probability that after a random 3x3 scramble, one side will be solved (not necessarily a layer, just a face)? Just curious because I got this scramble about a week ago: R2 B2 R2 D' L2 D F2 U F2 L2 D2 F U2 F D' F2 R' F D L2 F D'

Centers can be considered fixed. Corner and edge stickers of a given color must lie on the same face as the center of that color.

Consider a particular face such as the U face. Probability that the ULF sticker is on the U face is 4/24. The probability that the UFR sticker is on the U face, given that we know the ULF sticker already is, is 3/21. Similarly for the URB and UBL stickers, the probabilities can be given as 2/18 and 1/15. Similarly for the four U-color edge stickers, we get 4/24, 3/22, 2/20, and 1/18. Thus, the probability is (4/24)*(3/21)*(2/18)*(1/15)*(4/24)*(3/22)*(2/20)*(1/18) = 4!*4!/(24*21*18*15*24*22*20*18) = 1/(21*18*15*22*20*18) = 1/44906400.

The probability of at least one of the six faces being a solid color should be roughly (but not exactly) 6 times that or somewhere in the neighborhood of 1 in 7.5 million.
 
Top